Helen
Moving on from last week’s discussion, let me ask another question: if we accept that a relationship mindset is helpful, what would it look like If a disabled person isn’t just integrated into a church service, but is genuinely missed by the community when they aren’t there?
Craig
My gut response is to push back on the word ‘service’ as if church is all about public gatherings. Because if ‘church’ is defined by things we do, and what we do requires a certain capacity, then somebody who has limited capacity won’t be able to participate fully. For example, many churches have a platform of some sort which instantly prevents somebody in a wheelchair physically accessing the place from which certain things are done.
When we remodelled the inside of our church, I insisted that what was just a 6-inch platform was taken out. And it wasn’t because we had anybody with a wheelchair in the church at that point in time. It was because I didn’t want anything which enabled anybody to stand higher than other people and was also an impediment to full participation. And, of course, I was most often the person who was most often standing at the front. It was symbolic and I didn’t want it. Removing the step then enabled us to rearrange the seating so we could all see each other.
It could be said that having a platform in a public building is simply being practical. It helps those who are listening to see and hear the speaker. In the age of PA systems, I think it is more important to enable everyone to participate.
Helen
I have a question about the way a disabled person’s presence in our community could transform our understanding of what a Christian community could be. For me, it’s at the heart of what hospitality is, what leadership is, and what it means to be a disciple. And I think you’ve touched on that a little bit there, Craig – the idea that considering somebody with different needs to us makes us look much more widely at our surroundings, not just structurally but creating a place where every person is truly able to be themselves.
James
My thinking on this has been radically changed by an experience in the church that we’re part of, where one of the lay ministers is a wheelchair user. I’ve actually been impressed by the way in which we as a community have adapted to her. Because she’s sitting all the time as she leads means that we position ourselves so that we can see her, and the whole atmosphere of the place is changed for the better by the fact that she is part of us and takes a leading role within our community. We would be diminished without her. And the way we have adapted extends our inclusion. We have to be, and we want to be, inclusive. It would horrify us if in some way we did something that excluded her. And that’s part of our DNA now, I think, which is good. But it’s taken someone to come amongst us, and be part of us, to engender that change.
Craig
I think it’s important that this change of attitude becomes explicit, because what happens when the next person who has limitations, maybe of a completely different kind, comes in? That’ll be the real test as to whether you’ve bent the expectations and attitudes to include one person who is well known to you, but may still a struggle to incorporate people who are differently different.
James
Well, that’s when I think of the question that your therapist friend asked after your awful experience on the tube; “how would you want someone to intervene?” That’s where it requires those of us who have actually realised that this value of inclusion is an essential, and that people who are different are indispensable to us, to intervene if they see something that is not as it should be, or if we retract from someone with a different need. Then it’s on me to say “hey, we’re losing something here”.
Craig
I agree with you, and the reason I asked the question is because I read a really powerful Substack article where a pastor had an accident, and found himself having to use a wheelchair, and the church gradually accommodated themselves to him. The author of the article listed all the positive things the community learned from this experience.
But when their disabled pastor moved on, and somebody else came, the church went back to using the pulpit and all the disempowering practices that defined them before.
Julie
Can I take us back to the question about the creation of a community where there’s real depth in relationship. Helen, you asked the question about what it looks like when a disabled person is genuinely missed. Well, I think it would look the same as when we miss anybody, because genuine relationships get to a point, surely, where (and I’m not saying we don’t see the disability), it’s not about the disability. It’s about the person and what they bring and who they are. I liken it to a family gathering. If someone’s missing from a family gathering of ours, then we notice that they’re not there, whoever it is, whatever age and stage they’re at. So surely, in an ideal church community, you miss a person because of who they are and what they contribute, not in a transactional way, but in a ‘how they bless us’ way, because their presence makes a difference.
Helen
Yes, Julie, and that brings me back to something that seems to underpin a lot of what we’re talking about. I’m thinking of Paul’s words in 1 Corinthians when he writes about the weaker members of a community. And my question would be: are we right in defining disability as a weakness? We’ve just said that when we get to know a person, whoever they are, we recognise what they bring, not what their limitations are. So when we start to see beyond somebody’s limitations, we stop seeing their disability as a weakness and recognise their strengths.
Craig
You’re right. and think of the word ‘unpresentable’ in the same passage. It’s obviously a human judgment, not a judgment Paul is making, or one he’s attributing to God — he’s talking about the judgments of others. And so maybe he’s using the word weakness in the same sense. It’s about people who are perceived as being weak before others get to know them.
James
The ironic thing is the fact that the perceived weakness is located in the one who might have a disability, and yet it actually exposes weaknesses in me; the apparently able-bodied person, because it exposes weaknesses in my ability to accept others. So then, the person who is actually strong is the person who others might see as weak because they’re actually teaching me. I hope that I allow myself to be shaped by that experience, to be more relational.